What do you think you’re doing? Who hasn’t been stopped by that question? It’s one that constantly stalks us along the path from child to adult. In fact, it’s a bigger question than most of us ever realized.
BIG QUESTIONS
Do you like big questions? Me too. For instance, “Is Truth Beauty?” or “Will the universe end in a bang or a whimper?” or “What is a robin?” Take the robin question. I don’t know what a robin is, but the robin does and because of that, it knows how to find a worm or build a nest and, from my perspective at least, when to sing in the morning. Robins probably don’t spend much time thinking about what they are, because they already know and are simply too busy being robins. That’s the way it is with most things in nature. In the game of life, they are already winners.
People have their own big question. “What is a human being?” Like robins, we have been very busy and we have answered a lot of questions, but I still don’t think we know the answer to the one that really matters. In fact, in the game of life, we own the board and robins, as well as the rest of nature, are anxious to find out if we are winners.
Sometimes, with really big questions, it can be easier to find what is not the answer. For example, what is not being human? Is it the same as being inhumane or is it just being sub-human? Is a robin sub-human? Or is sub-human simply a human that misses the mark? A quick look around or a short walk through history and we know the answer. Pick up a paper. Examples abound. Pick a civilization. You probably don’t want to go there. We have been better at not being human than almost any other creature on the planet. Quite a distinction, when you think about it.
Still thinking? That’s what makes us special, isn’t it? Just think of everything we’ve thought. Our inventions could fill the world, and just about have. Our handiwork might appear to make us more special – more human, but it’s more like they’ve made us super-human. Can you fix a cell phone? Can anyone?? Instead, throw it away. Remember, we’re filling a world. The point is that our thoughts and the changes they’ve wrought have created a sphere that’s a bit beyond us. Our fabrications have taken on a life of their own and they’ve begun to consume us. Sadly, the super-human side of us has an unsustainable flavor, which is almost never helpful when answering really big questions.
So there we have it. The planet is busting with people, yet authentic human beings are in short supply, or at least in desperate need of being defined. “What is a human being?” The answer is important to everyone who values humanity – and to robins, because they would like to remain being robins. Each of us has responsibility for approximately one seven point five billionth of the answer. No fair using a calculator. If we can somehow find the answer, it will make it possible to ask more questions, to build nests, find worms and, most importantly, continue to sing in the morning.
Beautifully said ♥
Pretty heavy stuff!!! I’m probably wrong here but l would say Robin’s and all animals have ” instinct” and we have the ability to think,so l don’t think they give a hoot about us, but we can care about them in many different ways!!!
Welcome to the site Gary! We are definitely the thinkers of the animal world, but I wouldn’t sell robins short. After all, they were tweeting long before humans ever thought about doing it and, as far as I know, they haven’t said anything stupid yet. Seriously, I was speaking to what I believe the legitimate concerns of the greater living world would be and I have no reason to think that they don’t value their lives any less than we do. Thank you for commenting!
All good questions, big questions that need to be handled like Zen koans. Rather than rush to an answer. . . .live the questions. “Be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and try to love the questions themselves, like locked rooms and like books that are now written in a very foreign tongue. Do not now seek the answers, which cannot be given you because you would not be able to live them. And the point is, to live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the answer.” My most challenging question seems more intimate and direct than “What is a human being?” Some time ago I decided to live the question, “Who am I?” And the follow-up, “What do I mean by ‘I’?” Thanks for raising questions about our human relationship with other-than-human beings.
Live the question!!
I love it! Then the question becomes more rhetorical. An exclamation!
It would stand to reason then, that the question should be formulated carefully. The questions we ask might be indicative of the live we live.
Thanks Robert!
THE QUESTION THAT I LIVE
I have a question that I love
The question that I live
I asked a wise old tree once
No answer would it give
I probed a tiny house fly
I asked a tie-dyed sky
I asked with child-like wonder
The clouds gave no reply
I asked the wind politely
“Could you help me please?”
It left me there to ponder
and hurried thru the trees
There’s a field of wildflowers near here
A walk I often do
I asked the daisies growing there
but left without a clue
So now I’m asking YOU my friend
This question that I live
What wisdom can you share with me
What answer will you give
It’s just a simple question
that burns inside of me
It just a simple question…
God!…. HOW CAN IT BE ?!!!
HOW CAN IT BE ?!!!
Ed Mc